Mudslide with Peanut Butter Whiskey | Ninja SLUSHi Recipe

Screwball peanut butter whiskey mudslide Ninja SLUSHi recipe.
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Email

Disclosure: Product links, including Amazon links, will take you to our affiliate partner websites. We may earn a commission on purchases.

If you're a fan of creamy, indulgent drinks with a unique twist, the Skrewball Peanut Butter Mudslide is the perfect recipe to try. This delicious slushy combines the bold, nutty flavor of Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey with Margarita Man's Mudslide and Soft Serve Vanilla mixes. The result? A smooth, dessert-inspired drink that’s rich, chocolatey, and perfectly balanced with just the right hint of vanilla. It’s an ideal choice for those looking to shake up their usual drink rotation with something special and satisfyingly sweet.
What makes this recipe stand out is how simple it is to prepare without sacrificing flavor. The Margarita Man mixes take the guesswork out of achieving the perfect texture. Whether you’re hosting friends, winding down after a long day, or treating yourself to something fun, this mudslide slushy will feel like an indulgence you can make anytime right in your kitchen.
Margaria Man Mix.

Margarita Man Mixes — Save 15% with Coupon Code: SizzleAndSear

Margarita Man's mixes are crafted for commercial machines that function the same as your Ninja SLUSHi! While their margarita mix is a fan favorite, don't miss out on their other incredible flavors—Pina Colada, Rum Runner, Strawberry Daiquiri, Mojito, Mai Tai, Sangria, and more. These mixes make it easy to create your favorite frozen drinks in your SLUSHi!

Save 15% at Checkout with Margarita Man Coupon Code: SizzleAndSear

Get More Details

Recommended Accessory!

Stanley Stay-Chill Pitcher 64 oz | Cold Water, Beer, and Drink Pitcher with Lid | Large Capacity Durable Beverage Container with Handle | Insulated Stainless Steel | BPA-Free | Polar
Stanley Stay-Chill Pitcher 64 oz | Cold Water, Beer, and Drink Pitcher with Lid | Large Capacity Durable Beverage Container with Handle | Insulated Stainless Steel | BPA-Free | Polar
This 64 oz pitcher will hold most of a full batch, making it ideal for gatherings where you want to offer a variety of slushies! Will keep drinks slushed for 24+ hours when stored in the refrigerator.
$45.00 Amazon Prime
Get More Details

Pricing last updated on July 12, 2025 - 13:59 MDT. Pricing and images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Prep Time
2 minutes
Slushing Time
45 minutes
Total Time
47 minutes
SELECT A SIZE
64 oz Max-Fill Ninja SLUSHi Machine

Select the serving size based on your Ninja SLUSHi model: “Regular” for the version with a 64 oz max fill line (available at most retailers); “Large” for the version with a 74 oz max fill line (sold exclusively at Costco); and “Small” for the version with a 48 oz max fill line (sold exclusively at Walmart.)

INGREDIENTS
The SLUSHi
Optional Garnish
REQUIRED EQUIPMENT & SPECIAL INGREDIENTS
Commercial Quality Mudslide Mix

Margarita Man Mudslide Mix

Commercial Quality Vanilla Soft Serve Mix

Margarita Man vanilla soft serve mix.

Use coupon code SizzleAndSear to save 15%  + get free shipping when you order 6 mixes!

The Ninja SLUSHi

The original Ninja SLUSHi.

INSTRUCTIONS
 
  • Mix all the SLUSHi ingredients in your Ninja SLUSHi.
  • Set the machine to Spiked Slush mode, then manually increase by two bars.
    Select Spiked Slush to make the drink!
  • Run for ~45 minutes.
  • Dispense SLUSHi.
Optional Garnish
  • Top with optional whipped cream, chocolate sauce, and peanuts.

Share this recipe

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Email

Other equipment for this recipe:

Libbey Milkshake Glasses
Libbey Milkshake Glasses
  • Fountain Shoppe Glasses Set: Re-create that old-fashioned ice cream parlor look without leaving the house - or spending the dough with our vintage ice cream glasses ; these milk shake glasses set includes 6, 12-ounce root beer float glasses
  • Classic Design: Designed for both style and function, these tall ice cream sundae glasses are crafted from premium quality glass for safe and elegant use; the thick, tapered design of this milkshake glass helps keep frothy favorites cool for longer
  • Generously Sized: Get your family together with a little creativity and whole lot of ice cream, this large fountain shoppe soda glass makes it happen; these large sundae cups are ideal for ice cream, soda floats, smoothies, malt sundaes and more
$34.99 Amazon Prime
Get More Details

Pricing last updated on July 12, 2025 - 20:11 MDT. Pricing and images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Get More Ninja SLUSHi Recipes!

Get Frozen Drink Recipes and Kitchen Equipment Deals In Your Inbox

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Other Recipes

Spicy Seared Broccoli Side Dish
Pressure Cooker Chickpea and Sweet Potato Curry
Piña Colada | Ninja SLUSHi Recipe

Kitchen Equipment Reviews

Review: Breville PolyScience Control Freak Induction Cooker
Review: Matfer Bourgeat Exoglass Bouillon Strainer/Chinois
Ninja CREAMi Accessories

Food Articles

New Kitchen Tool: Anova Precision Chamber Vacuum Sealer
Simple Deep Frying Oil Solution if you Only Deep Fry a Couple Times a Year
A Guide to Selecting the Right Onion
Sizzle and Sear: Kitchen Equipment Reviews and Delicious Recipes!

Welcome to our kitchen! Sizzle and Sear is your source for delicious recipes and reviews of the best kitchen equipment for the serious home cook. Feel free to leave a comment on any of our articles or recipes. We look forward to hearing from you!

Copyright © 2025 Sizzle and Sear